Encrypted messages aren’t the same as private thoughts. | Engadget

A federal judge recently ruled that two of the men who plotted to kidnap Michigans governor did not make terrorist threats because they used an encrypted chat app to do so.

Since federal agencies and lawmakers have been trying to get encrypted comms backdoored by arguing that they are the tool of choice for terrorists, we wont blame you if your double-take gave you whiplash. It already boggles the mind to see a terrorism charge dropped against people doing domestic terrorism things, like plan and coordinate to attack the Capitol, blow up a bridge to stop police, murder law enforcement that got in the way to kidnap a US state governor, and murder said governor. But hang on.

Just try not to strain anything when we tell you that the judges reason not to charge the foiled kidnappers for threatening an act of terrorism is because 12th District Court Judge Michael Klaeren said that using encrypted comms is the same as having private thoughts.

After onboarding new members through mediums such as Facebook, the groups conversations took place in encrypted chats, reported The Detroit News. Further:

“There has to be some form of intent here to incite mayhem,” said Klaeren.

Klaeren added that an encrypted communication network, not accessible to the general public, was “in many respects no different than thinking the thought to yourself.”

Some charges still stand; they “will face charges of gang membership, felony firearm possession and providing material support for terrorist acts, but not making terrorist threats.” So, there’s a terrorism-scented charge in there. Yet it just doesn’t add up that one didn’t stand because… encryption.

See no evil, hear no evil, charge no evil

Essentially, Judge Klaeren didnt think using encrypted comms to plot acts of, well, terrorism, met the statute for discussing terrorist plotting because the threats werent visible to the public. If we follow this logic, terrorists coordinating on Telegram, Facebook Messenger, or similar encrypted apps are simply engaging in idle musing.

According to witness testimony the six men who plotted to violently overthrow the government, kidnap and harm Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer used an app called Wire.

Chip Somodevilla via Getty Images

Designed for group planning, Wire provides the strongest security for organizations looking to protect their communications and document sharing. Engadget reached out to Wire for comment; the company had no statement to make at this time.

We have to wonder how up to speed Judge Klaeren is on a lot of things. For one, encrypted communications are not telepathy. Even if a conversation on Telegram is only between two people, it is not at all like the thoughts in your head; its a private room with a closed door.

“Under Michigan law,” Engadget reported, “a person is guilty of making a terrorist threat if they ‘threaten to commit an act of terrorism and communicate the threat to any other person’.”

We presume there was more than one person in conversations among those who got the charges dropped. Though if you told us one of these kooks was having a big ol planning sesh on Wire with his imaginary Bald Eagle friend named Cooter, we wouldnt doubt you for a minute but only then the argument might hold a drop of water.

Luddite judge, meet the War on Encryption

Disturbingly, its among too many examples of judges, lawmakers and authorities making key, history- and life-altering decisions when they have absolutely no clue about how modern communication technologies work. Its reminiscent of Congressional hearings where Lindsey Graham complained to Jack Dorsey and Mark Zuckerberg about Snapchats addictive features, Missouri Representative Billy Long asked Zuck what Facemash was, and Florida Senator Bill Nelson asked him how to stop seeing ads for chocolate.

So, if you plot crimes like kidnapping and murder of a state governor through encryption, suddenly its not a terrorist threat or conspiracy anymore? The FBI might disagree.

How encrypted group comms work that they are not thoughts you think to yourself is a key part of prosecuting the January 6 Capitol rioters. Lets hope those cases dont come before Judge Klaeren (and well bet the FBI feels that way, too). In the March FBI Capitol riots indictment against the Proud Boys leaders, Count One for Conspiracy details the use of encrypted communications for group planning.

Judge Klaerens decision is whiplash-inducing for numerous reasons. Along with fresh worries about setting any precedent for Capitol riots cases, Klaerens private thoughts decision is beyond bizarre for those of us paying attention to the feds war on encryption. Federal and law enforcement arguments against keeping encrypted communications secure and intact are the opposite of what Klaeren just ruled.

FBI Director Christopher Wray testifies before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, March 2, 2021. Wray is condemning the Jan. 6 riot at the Capitol as domestic terrorism.  (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)


According to the FBI, encrypted comms are straight-up out loud zones for terrorist planning. In early March, FBI Director Christopher Wray told the House Homeland Security Committee the FBI was having a hard time disrupting domestic and foreign terrorists for reasons that included their frequent use of encrypted communications.

There are serious implications here. Aside from letting domestic terrorists off the hook for using a certain kind of app. If the 12th District Court decision by Judge Klaeren sets a precedent about encrypted communications and terrorists making plots, its a bad precedent.

Unless the judge just woke up from a coma, or returned from the Snap, theres no excuse. Even if Klaeren meant that the would-be kidnappers encrypted chats are somehow untouchable or unattributable, or if he meant that encryption-protected messages are essentially private thoughts because they cant be inferred either way, its a big deal that this statement was made. And its one that could shift the debate if it holds up on appeal.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *