Bowers & Wilkins new P17 true-wireless earbuds sound fantastic but they’re $400


The Bowers & Wilkins P17 may just well be the best-sounding true wireless earbuds.


David Carnoy/CNET

Bowers & Wilkins, the venerable British audio company acquired last year by Sound United, has released its first true wireless earbuds. They are well worth the wait — if you can afford them. The new flagship noise-canceling P17 earbuds sound terrific but cost a whopping $400 (349, AU$600). The step-down noise-canceling P15 buds, which I haven’t tried yet, retail for $250 (199, AU$370). Both are available to order now in charcoal or white.

Premium earbuds that cost $200 to $300 aren’t uncommon, but at $400, the P17 is in a class by itself, sort of like Apple’s AirPods Max in the over-ear noise-canceling arena. The Bang & Olufsen Beoplay E8 3rd-generation carry a list price of $350, but you can now find them discounted to a more palatable $250. Sennheiser’s Momentum True Wireless 2 buds are also down to $250 and Master & Dynamic just released its excellent MW08 buds for $300.

Aside from stellar sound — I’ll dig more into that shortly — the P17 buds have a few bonus feature that may or may not help you rationalize paying $400 for them. For starters, they’re the first earbuds I’ve encountered where the wireless charging case converts into a transceiver, so you can plug the case into the headphone port on an airplane’s inflight entertainment system and wirelessly stream audio from the case to the earbuds.

At 75g with the buds in the case (the P15 is 61g with the buds inside), the case is pretty light and fairly compact, though not as compact as that of theAirPods Pro. It looks like a smaller version of the case for theSony WF-1000XM3and — like that case — it can only stand upright if you flip it upside-down on its lid.

bowers-wilkins-pi5-white

The less expensive P15 (in white) looks the same as the P17 but has different drivers.


Bowers & Wilkins

Additionally, Bowers & Wilkins says the P17 supports Qualcomm aptX Adaptive wireless transmission (which includes the AptX HD codec) from compatible mobile devices, allowing for “high-resolution music transmission from suitable streaming services, such as Qobuz.” Also, the P17 “backs that high-resolution capability with 24-bit/48kHz wireless transmission between each earbud.” That makes the P17 one of few true wireless earbuds to support high-resolution audio “all the way from your music source to your ears,” according to Bowers & Wilkins, .

Alas, the list of mobile phones that currently support aptX Adaptive is quite limited — I do not own any of them — and I’ve always found that aptX’s implementation in devices is rather opaque. Apple’s iPhones support the AAC codec, not aptX (both the P15 and P17 support AAC streaming). And while we’re discussing Bluetooth audio codecs, which is what happens when you’re dealing with high-end wireless headphones, these earbuds don’t do Sony’s LDAC hi-res audio codec. Sorry, LDAC fans.

The case converts into a Bluetooth transceiver and can be connected to your computer or the headphone port an inflight entertainment system (a USB-C to 3.5mm cable is included).


David Carnoy/CNET

The P15 and P17 are equipped with Qualcomm’s QCC5126 chip, which used to be Qualcomm’s flagship Bluetooth Audio SoC (System-on-Chip). Qualcomm is now up to the more feature-richQCC5151, but the problem is a product like the P17 takes well over a year to develop — possibly well over two years, as Bowers & Wilkins says the buds were released after “an extensive period of development.” Products powered by the QCC5151 are probably months away from hitting store shelves.

The P17 and P15 look the same and feature a IP54 water-resistance rating (splashproof) along with Bluetooth 5.0. The P15 has a single 9.2mm driver while the P17 has an identically sized driver combined with a “high-frequency” balanced-armature driver. The P15 supports AAC and the standard AptX and AAC codecs, not the aforementioned AptX Adaptive and AptX HD — thus, no support for high-resolution audio streaming. Also, the P15’s case doesn’t convert into a Bluetooth transceiver, though it does charge wirelessly. And lastly, the P17 has 3 microphones on each bud — one is dedicated to picking up your voice during calls — while the P15 has two.

bowers-wilkins-pi7-in-street-1

The earbuds extend out from your ears.


Bowers & Wilkins

Battery life is slightly disappointing. The P17 is rated for 4 hours on a single charge at moderate levels with noise-canceling while the P15 is rated for up to 4.5 hours. The charging case gives you an additional 4 charges on the go.

Superlative sound

I still have to do some additional testing and comparisons but from what I’ve heard so far, the P17 are right up there with the best-sounding true wireless earbuds and may even be the best sounding overall. Like I said, I don’t have an aptX Adaptive-compatible mobile phone but I did stream high-resolution music from a MacBook to the buds using the case as a conduit and also used the Qobuz app to stream music from an iPhone 12 Pro and a Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra. (Side note: I’ve grown to prefer Qobuz to Tidal, another streaming service that offers high-resolution streaming).

In terms of sound, the P17 has exactly what I’m looking for in a good set of headphones: Accurate and articulate sounding with deep, well-defined bass, natural sounding mids, nicely detailed treble and a wide soundstage that gives the overall sound some largesse. Of course, you’ll need a tight seal to for optimal sound quality and noise-canceling performance, which is also good (the auto noise-canceling setting adapts the noise canceling according to the ambient sound in your environment).

bowers-wilkins-p17-vs-sony-wf-1000xm3-case

The Sony WF-1000XM3 case (left) vs. the P17’s case.


David Carnoy/CNET

While these are bigger buds that will extend out from your ears (most higher-end buds are larger), I found them comfortable to wear and was able to run with them without having them fall out of my ears (I got a secure fit). I don’t know if it’s a great idea to run with them. If one of the buds fell out of my ear for some reason, landing on the pavement and getting dinged up, I might cry if I had just paid $400 for them. But I wouldn’t have any trouble using them in the gym.

Like the AirPods Pro, these do have a transparency mode that allows sound into the buds. It’s not as good as the transparency mode on the AirPods Pro — there’s a slight hiss — but it’s decent. So too is the call quality. The noise reduction during calls is good (I was out on the streets of New York) and callers said they could hear me clearly (and I could hear them quite well), but they also said that while background noise was reduced, they heard a bit of hiss.

Based on my experience with earlier advanced earbuds like this that have multiple microphones, manufacturers tend to make some improvements with firmware upgrades and I wouldn’t be surprised if these did improve over time for making calls. Again, call quality is good right now, but when you’re dealing with a $400 headphone, you expect stellar. I had this issue with the Jabra Elite 75t when it first came out and it required several firmware upgrades to reach its full potential.

These have touch controls and they work relatively well, but they’re fairly limited. There are no volume controls on the buds themselves. It’s also worth noting that there are no EQ controls in the companion app for iOS and Android. I’m personally OK with that, particularly with a headphone like this that’s already perfectly tuned to my tastes, but some people like the options of playing around with the sound a bit.

Last but not least, if you’re wondering whether these have multipoint Bluetooth pairing, which allows you to pair the earbuds with two devices at the same time (such as a laptop and a smartphone), neither the P15 or P17 has that feature. But the earbuds do pair with multiple devices and in the app you can toggle between the devices you’ve previously paired, which I found worked pretty well. But it’s not quite as seamless an experience as having true multipoint Bluetooth pairing, which mainly comes in handy when you’re using your buds to listen to audio on your computer and a call comes in on your phone.

Once I get my hands on the P15, I’ll be able to put together a more thorough review, with a deeper dive into the sound of both buds. But for now the P17 have become my go-to earbuds for everyday listening. They may not surpass the high-end competition for noise-canceling and call quality, but they’re certainly hard to beat for overall sound quality.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *